In her guide to the post-beach ice cream run, Chatham real estate agent Shane Masaschi rounds up the best ice cream on Cape Cod, and Buffy’s comes in at number one as “The Chatham Icon,” ahead of Cape favorites Sundae School, Four Seas and Ice Cream Smuggler.
Buffy’s is as much a part of the town identity as the fish pier or the lighthouse.
Shane Masaschi
She calls out the classic shingled building and the pink bench out front, the small-batch ice cream, raspberry lime rickeys and thick milkshakes, and Buffy’s role as the home of Chatham Ice Cream Bars.
She even closes the guide with an invitation to celebrate a new home “with a scoop at Buffy’s.”