Chatham Ice Cream Bars Mini Logo

Home of

CHATHAM ICE CREAM BARS

Buffy’s Ice Cream, in beautiful downtown Chatham, became the home of Chatham Ice Cream Bars in April of 2022. The iconic ice cream shop has been serving Chatham’s only homemade ice cream since 1994,  and holds countless memories for generations of visitors. In addition to serving Cape Cod’s best ice cream, the distinctive building, pink bench and lively atmosphere of Buffy’s are as much a part of the town as the fish pier and lighthouse. Handcrafted ice cream, creative espresso drinks, friendly staff and summer memories — these are the hallmarks of a visit to Buffy’s. And now, so is a chance to enjoy The World’s Best Ice Cream Bars!

Buffy's Ice Cream Shop Interior
The image shows a circular, vintage-style stamp with the text Handcrafted with love Cape Cod and decorative elements like stars and a heart.
Visit Us
Cape cod's most distinctive treat

Pleasant Bay Bar

Chatham Light Bar

Schoolhouse Pond Bar

Great White Brownie Bar

Pink Bench Bar

Angler Brownie Bar

Lighthouse Beach ‘BRO’ Bar

Over Sand Bar

Cow Yard Bar

Chatham Oktoberfest Bar

Reviews...

- James M. Nov. 2023
Buffy's Ice Cream deserves a solid five stars! The ice cream sandwich is a heavenly treat that combines rich, creamy flavors with the perfect cookie texture, creating a delightful symphony for the taste buds. The bacon Affogato is a unique masterpiece, blending the smokiness of bacon with the boldness of espresso, resulting in a surprisingly harmonious and unforgettable experience. The innovative menu and exceptional quality make Buffy's a must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast.
- Domine Nov. 2023
The service is great! They were friendly & made great suggestions. The cookie dough was delicious & the affogato is yummy!
- Dylan May 2023
Delicious and open on a cold Saturday in February. The team working was welcoming and we had great chit chats about the Cape and the history of Buffy’s. Had Cinnamon, Ginger, strawberry and Salted Caramel and it was the best I’ve had in the US yet! Stop by - you won’t be disappointed!
- Fran Oct 2023
The cookies that surround the home made ice cream bar are baked by hand by my friend, Nolan Linsky. Outstanding.
- Margaux Feb 2024
Delicious and open on a cold Saturday in February. The team working was welcoming and we had great chit chats about the Cape and the history of Buffy’s. Had Cinnamon, Ginger, strawberry and Salted Caramel and it was the best I’ve had in the US yet! Stop by - you won’t be disappointed!
Chatham Ice Cream Bars Mini Logo